Greetings HaPPyPapPy832443!
(Man, that's a mouthful!) I think crab aprons can catch just about anything. I like them as a "come back" bait -- I combine them with a softer bait, and if the fish gets that bait on the first hit, I hope they "come back" and try for the apron. R-E-A-L hard to tear an apron off the hook....