A large bluefish or an edible size bluefish? Also shad smell terrible.
All personal preferences, I think. Here is my preference.A large bluefish or an edible size bluefish? Also shad smell terrible.
In Biloxi, MS fried mullet is known as Biloxi BaconAll personal preferences, I think. Here is my preference.
I have my own rule about the fish I catch. I tried the first fish of every species I caught if keeping was legal. I tried American shad once decades ago. To me, shad are just for fun. I tried a bluefish at 35". The fillet looked awful, full of bloody meat, and not firm. It wasn't worth to even cook. To me, the edible size bluefish is under 18" based on the smell, meat quality, taste and also based on the cook.
I tried a snakehead at 30". Snake head is quality food without fishy smell. All white firm meat it is. But, I keep sneak head to give away only.
I rare eat puppy drum. I love to catch specks. But I don't eat specks at all. I love mullet - very fish. They are good when fried. I love to eat spot, croaker (fishy),white perch and ribbon fish.
I rarely eat sheepshead and spadefish. I love triggerfish. I eat and I decide. I keep stripers, tautog and flounders for me. I keep blue cat under 22" to give away. Crapie, yellow perch and freshwater trout are tasty. I am very inconsistent.
My wife loves all fishes.