Fished incoming tide from 7:30 pm to 1 am (high tide about 10:30 pm). Caught about 5 schoolies casting into the lights with a 1/8 oz yellow spec rig with 4" yellow Gulp swimming mullet. Caught NOTHING on the eels and cut bait. As you look at the picture Dave sent, I was fishing in the far left corner of the "T". Figured that was closest to the deep water, but nothing. But there were others fishing everywhere else along the pier and no one was catching anything but schoolies. Biggest I saw caught was about 15". Also, there did seem to be a lot of grass in the water last night.
All in all, I think it's a good place to fish. I talked to the park ranger on the phone earlier in the day and she said there have been keepers caught out there this year. One thing to note is that the pier is only open through the end of striper season...they turn the lights off at night between 1 Jan and 1 Apr.