Pier and Surf Forum banner
1 - 20 of 25 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
4,411 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
It's not that you keep everything and eat none of it. It's not that you skirt the rules and it's not the fact you kept a lmb for fun. It's the fact that you have family this board doesn't come down hard on you.
WOW! Don't know how to take this post. Did I do something wrong? Please come out and tell me what is really on your mind. I fish every morning. I like to keep in touch with fishing people, and post reports. This is what I do now. My wife and I do eat a few fish now and then. We just ate a 21" rockfish I caught off a pier in Oxford MD. Wed. Is there something wrong with giving my neighbors pan fish? I don't give them rockfish. I release all rockfish, but will keep one to eat if it right size. Pleas tell me what this is all about. I want to see who agrees with you. Thanks! Getting ready to go pan fishing in a little while. Then going to Casino with my wife.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
322 Posts
Do your thing Andy, haters are going to hate. This guy probably can't catch any fish this season and looking to vent at someone who knows what they are doing. I'm pretty sure the fish you catch are put to good use by your neighbor.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
225 Posts
As long as the fish is not wasted and legal limits are followed...why not help your neighbors? When I go kayak fishing with some of my buddies and I only catch a few keepers of white perch, croakers or speckled trout- not enough for a good mess of fish for me, I ask them if they want to take my catch home with them...added together there are enough fish for a good meal for them and their family...fishing is supposed to be fun and a healthy, sustainable resource for the table...fish species are cyclic and there are years of over abundance followed by years of scarcity...usually caused by fluxiations of baitfish and the health of the fish habitat
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,411 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·
Bass fishermen are a strange bunch. I know about bass fishermen. I use to be one until I wised up and got out of bass clubs, and tournaments. I have so many funny stories about bass fishermen. Here is one. Look at these beautiful big bluegills I caught. " OH, I don't fish for them" LOL! Who cares you don't fish for them. I just wanted to show these huge gills. I think more of carp and cat fishermen then bass fisherman. I got to say, not all are strange, but a heck of a lot are. But we have to love them. The Bible tells us so. LOL!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
975 Posts
Hey Andy, I enjoy reading your reports & seeing your pics.

I know a lot if fly fishers who treat trout that way. Some get very indignant if trout are killed. I'm a bass angler and don't keep them usually, but for me it's a matter of taste, IMO they're not as good to eat as some other species. I would rather eat White Perch, Bluegills or even catfish than bass. Usually the only time I'll keep a bass to eat is if it's hurt real bad, provided it's legal of course. I like to eat trout too, just never spent a lot of time fishing for them. Hatchery trout I'll keep & eat a few, wild trout I prefer to release them all.
I prefer to release Rockfish too, but have kept a few legal schoolie size over the years to eat. I've never kept one over 25" in the past, even though a few were caught. Personal preference that's all, but won't condemn anyone for keeping any legal size or species of fish if they choose to do so.

Opinions & attitudes are always going to vary.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
7,090 Posts
you can become a target when you do fishing reports, I used to do a lot of reports on tidalfish and it would amaze at how mean some people would become, people that don't even know me calling me a liar and all.
I haven't posted a report in the last 10 + years for the same reason. Now I just try to pass on what I've learned. Can't get in trouble that way.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
631 Posts
you can become a target when you do fishing reports, I used to do a lot of reports on tidalfish and it would amaze at how mean some people would become, people that don't even know me calling me a liar and all.
Maybe you should take a cue from andypat, get over it, and move on.
I'm confident in saying he ain't gonna be talking about what happened to him for as long as some have been carrying on about TidalFish on another popular website out there. No need to bring any of that here, but all indications are that you have some reason stuck in your inner self to do so.
What happened to him, and what you say happened to you, goes on in every (fishing) website out there. Shame it happened to you. I enjoyed your contributions and reports. Also enjoyed reading andy's adventures.
Now those reports are gone, and for what reason? Maybe this can explain it better than I can:
http://psychcentral.com/blog/archives/2014/07/22/learning-to-let-go-of-past-hurts-5-ways-to-move-on/
 
1 - 20 of 25 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top